Was Carroll offside?

[Badlands]

You won’t see a more obvious offside this season.
I was in line and it was way off.
Can’t understand why some are trying to justify the decision!

 

[STID2017]

Personally I think Hamer should have done better, although Carroll shouldn't have got anywhere near the box

If only I had your insight ... :lol:

 

[WalterBoyd]

I disagree, I think Carroll shouldn't have got anywhere near the box and personally I think Hamer should have done better.

P.s. can Patterson play for Wales.