• Due to a recent spam attack on the site we have switched user registration to require administrator approval. Please bear with us as this could take a few hours to approve new registrations (depending on availability) but all genuine registrations will be approved

Adam Idah

  • Thread starter Thread starter JA News
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies: Replies 194
  • Views Views: Views 14,423
Sounds like a great guy, I didn't know about the fractured foot injury when he first signed.
Full of praise for Vipotnik too, both might be rivals for the striker spot but I think both offer very different profiles in their playing style and there is definitely games that will suit one more than the other and its even possible that they could both see time on the pitch together in the right formation.
 
Fair points, although i think you were generous 🙂. Burgess should be thanked and sold, Cabango and key should stay on the bench as impact subs\squad players. We need two CB’s with hight and pace which one of them (At least) should be a ball playing defender. For the RB, i would love to see Lissah and Parker compete for the shirt.
He is massively affected by confidence- but Key can be top quality at times. I think the competition should be Key and Lissah at RB with s loan for Parker
 
If you think a player who has zero starts, zero assists and zero goals at a League One side is adequate depth.. then I think we differ.
Bobby has some potential - but in 10 games he has started on the bench 10 times and has played only 12% of available minutes.
Looking forward, I am way more excited to see Lissah compete with Key at RB and Congreve compete with Ronald at RW.
I am also getting increasingly concerned about Burgess (and to a lesser extent Cabango). He has become a high wage liability.
I know that Congreve has had an excellent season for Dundee, but today against Celtic, he didn't offer much more than Ronald does. He was excellent picking up the ball at the center of the pitch and bringing it forward, but his crossing left much to be desired and he wasn't exactly blowing by his man.

He did show a good eye for passing around the box and at least one of his shots was on target--even if it did not challenge the keeper. Obviously Celtic are a cut above the rest of the SPL and much of the Championship, but I think he'll need to improve to unseat Ronald. At the very least, I'd like to see him give Ronald a good scare, but it will probably come down to his performance in preseason as to whether or not he sticks or is loaned/sold.
 
Not that I like to compare VP and Idah as they both offer different aspects to the game. What Idah does well is his ability to run the channels and create opportunities. While VP hold up play and has better defense mind and more killer instinct. If anything I would like to see Idah more selfish. He has tendency to pass in the box than shoot at times.
 
Not that I like to compare VP and Idah as they both offer different aspects to the game. What Idah does well is his ability to run the channels and create opportunities. While VP hold up play and has better defense mind and more killer instinct. If anything I would like to see Idah more selfish. He has tendency to pass in the box than shoot at times.
I might be in the minority but I think Idah looks at his best for us when he’s out wide taking on his man. I know he might not want to play there but I honestly think he could suit the RW role quite well.
 
I might be in the minority but I think Idah looks at his best for us when he’s out wide taking on his man. I know he might not want to play there but I honestly think he could suit the RW role quite well.

I wouldnt be averse to him out wide. I could see him as a Bolasie type direct but clumsy (I dont know what im going to do let alone my opposing full back) which can be effective. He has the physicality and pace to do it.
 
Idah one for the future. Got a feeling we’ll get good money for Vip and he’ll need to be put him in the shop window.
Vipotnik is away, his improved contact last month gives him a massive bung and gives us another 5 million on his price, winner winner chicken dinner. What are you not seeing here? Adam Idah will be starting up top for us next season aye ...
#bookmark
 
Vipotnik is away, his improved contact last month gives him a massive bung and gives us another 5 million on his price, winner winner chicken dinner. What are you not seeing here? Adam Idah will be starting up top for us next season aye ...
#bookmark

I would be perfectly happy with Idah starting and some of the money we would get for Vipotnik invested in another youngish striker from the continent as backup.

Ironically Vip had one golden chance from open play today and smashed it over the crossbar. Doesn't matter because he has been finishing those chances all season and scored his two penalties with aplomb, but I did wonder what the reaction would have been if it had been Idah who missed that chance?
 
Back
Top