Adam Idah

[DJack]

It was my 74th on Wednesday,

Happy 74th to you, then!

 

[Pegojack]

It was my 74th on Wednesday,

Belated happy birthday, D.

 

[Manselton Jack]

So far Idah hasn't justified his transfer fee but yesterday he was excellent when he came on, long may it continue. I really hope that's a sign of things to come.
I don't understand why so many posters have to nail their colours to the mast & overhype a player or right them off.
For every Vipotnic there's a Kuharevych .

 

[Swanjaxs]

That was an eye-opener yesterday. Idah looked really good in his cameo.
This opens up a fantastic opportunity for us to potentially cash in on VIP, bringing in a cheaper striker as competition, and then invest in the areas of the team that are desperate.
If we start next season with Burgess, Ronald, no right back. We will be negligent.

Adam Idah is quality, we paid over the top for him at the time, but we will make a profit on him when he goes. Bookmark away

 

[Swanjaxs]

So far Idah hasn't justified his transfer fee but yesterday he was excellent when he came on, long may it continue. I really hope that's a sign of things to come.
I don't understand why so many posters have to nail their colours to the mast & overhype a player or right them off.
For every Vipotnic there's a Kuharevych .

He literally hasn't had a run of games to get up to speed, trust me, when Vipotnik goes (for a big profit) you will eat your words
There you go, that's my colours firmly nailed

 

[Manselton Jack]

He literally hasn't had a run of games to get up to speed, trust me, when Vipotnik goes (for a big profit) you will eat your words
There you go, that's my colours firmly nailed

No he hasn't but he hasn't deserved to either given his performances but I hope you're right,
I just want what's best for the Swans

 

[Swanjaxs]

No he hasn't but he hasn't deserved to either given his performances but I hope you're right,
I just want what's best for the Swans

He hasn't had a run of games, it's that simple really, this time last year Vipotnik was on the bench every game. See where I'm coming from...

 

[swannage]

Adam Idah is quality, we paid over the top for him at the time, but we will make a profit on him when he goes. Bookmark away

I don't think we paid over the top for him. In comparison Kyogo was £9m, Broadhead £8.5m. I'd say Idah is better than both, and younger, and cheaper

 

[Manselton Jack]

He hasn't had a run of games, it's that simple really, this time last year Vipotnik was on the bench every game. See where I'm coming from...

Yes but I'd like to think you can see my point of view as well...

 

[Swanjaxs]

I don't think we paid over the top for him. In comparison Kyogo was £9m, Broadhead £8.5m. I'd say Idah is better than both, and younger, and cheaper

Fair, but Celtic paid Norwich 11 million for Idah rising to 13 million.
I'd have given up my left leg to keep Kyogo at Celtic, but he chose to chase the coin. He chose to jump ship.
Saying that, I'd have Kyōgo Furuhashi back at Paradise in a heartbeat

 

[Swanjaxs]

Yes but I'd like to think you can see my point of view as well...

Fair enough

 

[Jackareme]

So far Idah hasn't justified his transfer fee but yesterday he was excellent when he came on, long may it continue. I really hope that's a sign of things to come.
I don't understand why so many posters have to nail their colours to the mast & overhype a player or right them off.
For every Vipotnic there's a Kuharevych .

Actually - so was Eom!! He bemuses me - the stats are weak - but my eyeballs tells me he is absolute quality at times. Ronalds stats exactly match my eyeballs
He should never be starting

 

[IsraJack]

That was an eye-opener yesterday. Idah looked really good in his cameo.
This opens up a fantastic opportunity for us to potentially cash in on VIP, bringing in a cheaper striker as competition, and then invest in the areas of the team that are desperate.
If we start next season with Burgess, Ronald, no right back. We will be negligent.

Friday’s game showed that there is a chance that Idah might be a better striker than VIP. The way he shook off the defender was very impressive and so was his assist - Two qualities VIP lacks a little bit . But the mentality is what makes him a question mark and the other a top scorer.

 

[IsraJack]

If you think a player who has zero starts, zero assists and zero goals at a League One side is adequate depth.. then I think we differ.
Bobby has some potential - but in 10 games he has started on the bench 10 times and has played only 12% of available minutes.
Looking forward, I am way more excited to see Lissah compete with Key at RB and Congreve compete with Ronald at RW.
I am also getting increasingly concerned about Burgess (and to a lesser extent Cabango). He has become a high wage liability.

Fair points, although i think you were generous . Burgess should be thanked and sold, Cabango and key should stay on the bench as impact subs\squad players. We need two CB’s with hight and pace which one of them (At least) should be a ball playing defender. For the RB, i would love to see Lissah and Parker compete for the shirt.

 

[Cwmbwrla Floatabout]

If you think a player who has zero starts, zero assists and zero goals at a League One side is adequate depth.. then I think we differ.
Bobby has some potential - but in 10 games he has started on the bench 10 times and has played only 12% of available minutes.
Looking forward, I am way more excited to see Lissah compete with Key at RB and Congreve compete with Ronald at RW.
I am also getting increasingly concerned about Burgess (and to a lesser extent Cabango). He has become a high wage liability.

that's fair. Do you think that Wales and Burgess could do with a season or two on loan with Falkirk or Kilmarnock?